Icrometric domains, which are sometimes referred to as platforms, were first

April 11, 2018

Icrometric domains, which are sometimes referred to as platforms, were first inferred in cells by dynamic studies [19-21]. However, morphological Oxaliplatin site evidence was only occasionally reported and most of the time upon fixation [22-25]. In the past decade, owed to the development of new probes and new imaging methods, several groups have presented evidence for submicrometric Pemafibrate price domains in a variety of living cells from prokaryotes to yeast and mammalian cells [26-32]. Other examples include the large ceramide-containing domains formed upon degradation of sphingomyelin (SM) by sphingomyelinase (SMase) into ceramide (Cer) in response to stress [33-35]. However, despite the above morphological evidences for lipid rafts and submicrometric domains at PMs, their real existence is still debated. This can be explained by several reasons. First, lipid submicrometric domains have often been reported under nonphysiological conditions. For example, they have been inferred on unfixed ghosts by highresolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) upon cholesterol extraction by methyl-cyclodextrin [36]. Second, lipid or protein clustering into domains can be controlled by other mechanisms than cohesive interaction with Lo domains, thus not in line with the lipid phase behavior/raft hypothesis (see also Section 5). Kraft and coll. have recently found submicrometric hemagglutinin clusters at the PM of fibroblasts that are not enriched in cholesterol and not colocalized with SL domains found in these cells [37]. Likewise, whereas spatiotemporal heterogeneity of fluorescent lipid interaction has been found at the PM of living Ptk2 cells by the combination of super-resolution STED microscopy with scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, authors have suggested alternative interactions than lipid-phase separation to explain their observation [38]. Third, other groups did not find any evidence for lipid domains in the PM. For example, using protein micropatterning combined with single-molecule tracking, Schutz and coll. have shown that GPI-anchored proteins do not reside in ordered domains at the PM of living cells [39]. Therefore, despite intense debates, plenty of lipid domains have been shown in the literature but their classification is still lacking. We propose to distinguish two classes of lipid domains, the lipid rafts and the submicrometric lipid domains, based on the following distinct features: (i) size (20-100nm vs >200nm); (ii) stability (sec vs min); and (iii) lipid enrichment (SLs and cholesterol vs several compositions, not restricted to SLs and cholesterol). Whether these two types of domains can coexist within the same PM or whether some submicrometric domains result from the clustering of small rafts under appropriate conditions, as proposed by Lingwood and Simons [40], are key open questions that must be addressed regarding biomechanical and biophysical properties of cell PMs. In addition, to clarify whether lipid domains can be generalized or not in biological membranes, it is crucial to use appropriate tools in combination with innovative imaging technologies and simple well-characterized cell models. In this review, we highlight the power of recent innovative approaches and modern imaging techniques. We further provide an integrated view on documented mechanisms that govern the formation and maintenance of submicrometric lipid domains and discuss their potential physiopathological relevance.Author Manuscript Author Manuscript Author Manuscript Auth.Icrometric domains, which are sometimes referred to as platforms, were first inferred in cells by dynamic studies [19-21]. However, morphological evidence was only occasionally reported and most of the time upon fixation [22-25]. In the past decade, owed to the development of new probes and new imaging methods, several groups have presented evidence for submicrometric domains in a variety of living cells from prokaryotes to yeast and mammalian cells [26-32]. Other examples include the large ceramide-containing domains formed upon degradation of sphingomyelin (SM) by sphingomyelinase (SMase) into ceramide (Cer) in response to stress [33-35]. However, despite the above morphological evidences for lipid rafts and submicrometric domains at PMs, their real existence is still debated. This can be explained by several reasons. First, lipid submicrometric domains have often been reported under nonphysiological conditions. For example, they have been inferred on unfixed ghosts by highresolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) upon cholesterol extraction by methyl-cyclodextrin [36]. Second, lipid or protein clustering into domains can be controlled by other mechanisms than cohesive interaction with Lo domains, thus not in line with the lipid phase behavior/raft hypothesis (see also Section 5). Kraft and coll. have recently found submicrometric hemagglutinin clusters at the PM of fibroblasts that are not enriched in cholesterol and not colocalized with SL domains found in these cells [37]. Likewise, whereas spatiotemporal heterogeneity of fluorescent lipid interaction has been found at the PM of living Ptk2 cells by the combination of super-resolution STED microscopy with scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, authors have suggested alternative interactions than lipid-phase separation to explain their observation [38]. Third, other groups did not find any evidence for lipid domains in the PM. For example, using protein micropatterning combined with single-molecule tracking, Schutz and coll. have shown that GPI-anchored proteins do not reside in ordered domains at the PM of living cells [39]. Therefore, despite intense debates, plenty of lipid domains have been shown in the literature but their classification is still lacking. We propose to distinguish two classes of lipid domains, the lipid rafts and the submicrometric lipid domains, based on the following distinct features: (i) size (20-100nm vs >200nm); (ii) stability (sec vs min); and (iii) lipid enrichment (SLs and cholesterol vs several compositions, not restricted to SLs and cholesterol). Whether these two types of domains can coexist within the same PM or whether some submicrometric domains result from the clustering of small rafts under appropriate conditions, as proposed by Lingwood and Simons [40], are key open questions that must be addressed regarding biomechanical and biophysical properties of cell PMs. In addition, to clarify whether lipid domains can be generalized or not in biological membranes, it is crucial to use appropriate tools in combination with innovative imaging technologies and simple well-characterized cell models. In this review, we highlight the power of recent innovative approaches and modern imaging techniques. We further provide an integrated view on documented mechanisms that govern the formation and maintenance of submicrometric lipid domains and discuss their potential physiopathological relevance.Author Manuscript Author Manuscript Author Manuscript Auth.